Learn/Websites
Video article · Websites

What a contractor website costs, and how to tell if it paid off

Skip the sticker price. Learn the hidden costs nobody quotes, what to ask an agency, and the payback math that shows if a site earns its keep.

Rob SatromPublished November 15, 2026 · 4 min read
Quick answer

Most contractors ask what a website costs. The better question is what it should bring back. A cheap site that never books a consult is the most expensive one you can buy. Do the payback math first, then compare quotes.

1:35Watch the videoWhat a Contractor Website Should Cost and Bring Back

We made a matching video for this topic. This article goes further into the hidden costs and the questions to ask.

The costs that never make it onto the quote

A quote lists the build. It rarely lists what comes after. Watch for these.

  • Plugin updates and hacks. Somebody has to handle them sooner or later, and it's usually you.
  • Developer fees for every change. If you pay to swap a word or a photo, you stop making changes. The site goes stale.
  • Leads you never tracked. You can't tell which ones became jobs, so you can't tell what worked.
  • Copy that doesn't sell. The site looks fine and says nothing a buyer cares about.
  • A rebuild in a few years. Cheap builds tend to get replaced.

Add those up and the cheap quote isn't cheap anymore.

What actually drives the price

Five things move the number. Use them as a checklist when you compare quotes.

  1. Your message. Can a stranger get it in about five seconds?
  2. Your pages. One page for each core service and each town you serve.
  3. Your photos and video. Real before and afters beat stock every time.
  4. How leads get captured and followed up. Forms, calls, texts and a quick reply.
  5. Who can update it. If you need a developer for every edit, that's a cost.

Two quotes can look the same on paper and cover totally different things. Ask each agency to match them against this list.

What a site that sells includes

A clear message that a stranger gets in about five seconds. Service pages, town pages and project pages with real before and afters. Reviews, video testimonials and a simple way to book a consult. And it gets tracked, maintained and improved instead of built once and forgotten.

That last piece matters. A site isn't a brochure. It's a salesperson that works at night. It needs coaching like any other.

Do the payback math

This is the part most owners skip. Take your average project and your margin. Ask how many extra signed jobs a year the site has to win to pay for itself.

Take an example with made-up numbers. Say your average remodel brings in a $40,000 project at a 20% margin, which is $8,000. If the site costs $8,000 over its first year, one extra signed job covers it. Two jobs and you're ahead. Use your real numbers, not mine.

For most remodelers and builders, the answer is one or two jobs. That's a much easier question than is this expensive.

Ask your agency one question

Which jobs did the website book?

If they can show you calls and forms by source, tied to signed work, great. If they can't, you're flying blind. Most businesses waste 30 to 80% of their marketing spend, and a big reason is that nobody can see what's working.

Three kinds of site, side by side

It helps to see the options in one place.

  • A DIY template. Cheapest up front. You do the writing, the photos and the setup. It works if you have time and good instincts, and it often looks like everyone else's.
  • A typical agency site. Looks nicer. You usually get a design and a handoff. Updates cost extra, and tracking is often an afterthought.
  • A site that sells. Built around your message. Real photos, pages for each service and town, tracking set up from day one, and someone keeps improving it after launch.

The third costs more at the start. It also tends to be the only one you can tie to signed work. If you can't measure it, you can't tell if it's worth it.

What to hand your agency before the quote

You get better quotes when you give better inputs. Before you call anyone, gather your five best before and after projects, your service list, the towns you want work in and your average job size. Say what you want the site to do in plain words, like book six more design consults a month. Then ask each agency how they'd get you there.

If an agency starts with colors and page templates instead of your message and your numbers, that tells you something.

The mistake to avoid

Don't pick on price alone. The lowest quote usually leaves out photos, tracking, updates and town pages. You end up paying for them later, or you never get them and the site never works.

Your Monday-morning list

  • Write down your average project size and margin.
  • Calculate how many jobs the site must win to pay off.
  • List the pages you need, by service and by town.
  • Collect your best before and after photos.
  • Ask each agency what's included for tracking and updates.
  • Ask every agency, which jobs did the site book?

Comparing quotes right now?

Book a $99 audit call with me first. I'll look at your site and your tracking, and tell you what I'd want in a quote. You'll leave with your top three fixes. Book here: https://www.feedbackwrench.com/book

Questions people ask

How much does a website cost for a contractor?

The sticker price matters less than what the site brings back. Cost depends on your message, your pages, your photos and video, how leads get captured and who updates it. For current Feedbackwrench pricing, see our pricing page.

How do I know if a website is worth it?

Take your average project and your margin, then ask how many extra signed jobs a year the site has to win to pay for itself. For most remodelers and builders, the answer is one or two.

What hidden costs come with a cheap website?

Plugin updates and hacks, a developer fee for every change, leads you never tracked, copy that doesn't sell and a full rebuild a few years later. Each one is small, but together they make a cheap site expensive. Ask for these costs in writing before you sign.

What should I ask an agency before I sign?

Ask which jobs the website booked. If they can't show you, you're paying for a site you can't measure. Also ask who updates it and what each change costs.

What pages does a contractor site need?

Service pages, town pages and project pages with real before and afters. Add reviews, video testimonials and a simple way to book a consult.

Rob Satrom
Rob Satrom, owner of Feedbackwrench

Rob built Feedbackwrench and Nuance Financial Tax & Accounting. Since 2015, our team has helped transform 550+ small businesses with marketing, strategy and systems.

Your next step

Want a second set of eyes on your marketing?

Book the $99 Sales & Marketing Audit. It's one live call with a scored look at your marketing and your top three fixes, in order. If nothing's broken, we'll tell you that too.