Nobody wakes up wanting services. They wake up with a problem, and your homepage reads like a taco menu. Lead with the problem they feel today, say it in their words and offer one next step, and only one.
0:31Watch the videoMenu Versus Problem: Lead Your Homepage With the Problem
We made a short video on this tip. This article shows how to rewrite your homepage from menu to problem, with a method you can use today.
What a menu does to a visitor
Picture a restaurant that hands you a list. We have fish tacos, chicken tacos, beef tacos and veggie tacos. That's fine if you already know you want tacos. But a stranger who's just hungry doesn't care about your list. They want to know if you can fix their hunger.
Most service business homepages do the same thing. They list what they sell. Accounting, tax, payroll, advisory. Roofing, siding, gutters, windows. The visitor has to do the work of figuring out which line matches their problem.
It's not a menu. You've got to pull on problems.
Start with the problem they feel today
A person lands on your site because something is bugging them. They're worried about a tax bill. A leak is getting worse. They can't tell if their business is making money. That feeling is what you want to name.
Write it in their words, not yours. Compare two headlines for an accountant.
- Tax, accounting and advisory services.
- Are you overpaying in taxes?
The second one stops a person who is worried about that. The first one blends in with every other firm.
How to find their words
You don't have to guess. Pull them from places where people say them out loud.
- Your sales calls. What do people say in the first two minutes?
- Your emails and form messages. Look for repeated phrases.
- Your reviews. What did customers say they were worried about before?
- Your competitors' reviews. What do their customers complain about?
Write down phrases that repeat. Those are your headlines.
The rewrite in four steps
- Name the problem. One line, in their words.
- Say what changes. One line about the result.
- Show you've done it. A rating, a number you can back up or a short quote.
- Offer one next step. A single button with a clear label.
Then place your services lower on the page or on separate pages.
One next step, and only one
A menu of choices creates hesitation. Pick one main action, like Book a call or Get a quote, and use the same wording on every button. If someone isn't ready, offer a smaller step, like a free review or a checklist, in a clearly secondary spot.
Too many buttons make people stop and think. Thinking is where you lose them.
Where your services go
Services still matter. They just don't belong at the top. Give each one its own page that explains it, shows examples and answers common questions. Link to those pages from your homepage, in a short section lower down.
That way, visitors who know what they want can jump to it. Visitors who only know their problem get a headline that speaks to them.
A worked example
This one is made up. A small accounting firm's homepage opens with a list: tax preparation, bookkeeping, payroll, advisory. A visitor who runs a landscaping company has to guess which one fits. The firm rewrites the top. The headline says are you overpaying in taxes. The line below says we plan with you all year so you keep more of what you make. Under it sit a Google rating, a short owner quote and a single button, Book a discovery call. The services move to a section further down with links to each page. Nothing else changes, but the page now talks to the person who landed on it.
A simple test for your new headline
Read the headline out loud to someone in your target group, or to a friend who runs a business. Ask what they think you do and who it's for. If they can't say it back, rewrite it. Then check three things.
- Does it name a problem a real person would say?
- Could any competitor use it as is? If yes, make it more specific.
- Is it clear in five seconds on a phone?
Test two versions against each other for a few weeks if you have the traffic. Watch for more calls, more form fills and longer time on the page. The best headline is the one that makes the right visitor stay.
Problem language for different trades
Every trade has problems that people say out loud. A few examples to get you thinking, all illustrative.
- Accountants: Am I overpaying in taxes? Is my business actually making money?
- Remodelers: Our kitchen doesn't work for our family. Will this project run over budget?
- Roofers: Is that leak going to get worse? How do I know who to trust?
- Bookkeepers: I'm behind on my books and tax time is coming.
Notice they're all questions or worries in plain words. Borrow the form, then use your own customers' language.
The mistake to avoid
The mistake is thinking a problem headline is negative. It isn't. You're showing you understand. The page then moves from the problem to a plan and a result. Just don't dwell on the pain. Name it, then move to what you do about it.
Your Monday-morning list
- Read your homepage like a stranger. Count how many lines are a list of services.
- Write three problem headlines in your customers' words.
- Pick the one that you hear most often.
- Rewrite the top of the page using the four steps.
- Pick one button and use it everywhere.
Want me to read your homepage the way a stranger does?
Book the $99 audit call. I'll tell you where it sounds like a menu. And you'll get your top three fixes. Book here: https://www.feedbackwrench.com/book
Questions people ask
Why doesn't a list of services work on a homepage?
Nobody wakes up wanting services. They wake up with a problem. A menu makes the visitor do the work of matching their problem to your list, and many won't bother.
What should the homepage headline say?
Lead with the problem they feel today, in their words. For an accountant, that might be a question like are you overpaying in taxes. Then show how you help.
How many calls to action should I have?
Offer one next step, and only one. Repeat the same wording all the way down the page so visitors always know what to do.
Where do my services go then?
Put them on their own pages, linked from the homepage. The homepage hooks the visitor with the problem, and service pages give the details.






