Your homepage probably reads like a menu. Fish tacos, chicken tacos, we've got tacos. Customers don't want a menu. They want a diagnosis. Pull on one real problem, say it plainly and offer one next step.
1:57Watch the videoStop Selling a Menu: Pull on a Problem Instead
A menu doesn't make anyone feel anything
Ask yourself this. When was the last time a list of services made anybody feel something? Probably never.
A menu lists everything you do. Accounting. Bookkeeping. Tax prep. Payroll. Advisory. It's accurate, and it's invisible. Nobody wakes up in the morning wanting services. They wake up with a problem.
A problem is different
A problem asks something that stings. For example, when did a pro last look at your tax return for overpaid taxes?
That question does something a list can't. It makes the reader stop and think. It makes you the proactive adviser, not the once-a-year filer. And a menu sounds like every other firm, while a problem sounds like someone who has been paying attention.
Customers move when you pull on a problem, not when you list services. So pick the one they already feel, and say it first.
Think diagnosis, not menu
A doctor who handed you a menu of treatments before asking what hurts wouldn't last long. A good one asks what's wrong, finds the pain first, and then talks about the fix.
Do the same on your homepage. Find the pain first, and then talk about the fix.
Four steps to write it
Number one, find your string to pull. For accountants, it's overpaying in taxes and an accountant who only reacts. For other businesses, it'll be different. What keeps your customer up at night? What do they complain about before they hire you?
Number two, ask it out loud. Have you done an S corp? When did anyone last look for overpaid taxes? Simple, direct questions that make people think.
Number three, sprinkle the services in. After the problem, mention what you do. We do your accounting, bookkeeping and taxes together, so you have books you can defend. The services support the problem. They don't lead.
Number four, end with one next step. Book a call. Make it the only button that matters on the page.
A before and after (illustration only)
Before: "We offer accounting, bookkeeping, payroll, tax preparation and advisory services for small businesses."
After: "When did anyone last look at your return for overpaid taxes? If your accountant only shows up once a year to file, you might be leaving money on the table. We do your accounting, bookkeeping and taxes together, so you have books you can defend and a plan to keep more of what you earn. Book a call and let's take a look."
Same business, same services. The second version starts with the reader's problem, mentions the services in context, and ends with a single action.
Two mistakes to avoid
Mistake one is listing every service, so nothing in particular catches their eye. When everything is on the page, nothing stands out. Choose the problem that matters most and lead with that. Put the full list lower on the page or on service pages.
Mistake two is thick, manipulative language. Owners can smell that from a mile away, and it's disgusting. Think of the pushy sales pages that scream about disaster and urgency. It doesn't build trust. It makes people close the tab.
Pull on one real problem, say it plainly, and offer one next step.
How to find the right problem
If you're not sure which problem to lead with, try these.
- Listen to what new clients say in the first call. The words they use are the problem.
- Think about what clients say right after you help them. "I didn't know that was possible" is a clue.
- Ask your best clients what they were worried about before they hired you.
- Look at the questions people ask over and over.
You'll start to see the same one or two themes. That's your string to pull.
A worked example (illustration only)
Say you run a landscaping company that does design and build.
- Your old homepage lists lawn care, hardscape, planting, lighting and irrigation.
- You talk to a few clients and hear the same worry. They've had a landscaper start a project and disappear.
- You rewrite the top of the page around that. "Ever had a landscaper start a job and then go quiet?"
- Below it, you explain how your process keeps clients informed, and mention the services you do.
- You end with one button, "Book a site visit."
The services are still there, but now they answer a fear instead of reciting a list.
Your Monday morning list
- Read your homepage out loud and notice where it reads like a menu.
- Write down the one problem your customers feel most.
- Turn it into a plain question and put it at the top of the page.
- Move your service list lower and tie it to the problem.
- Cut every button but one and make it the next step you want.
- Show it to someone outside your business and ask what they think you do.
A quick checklist
- Does the page start with a problem, not a list?
- Is the language plain, not pushy?
- Do the services support the problem?
- Is there one clear next step?
Want a second set of eyes on your homepage?
Want a second set of eyes on your homepage? Book the $99 audit call with me. I'll tell you what a stranger sees when they land on it. Bring your homepage and I'll bring the red pen. Then I'll hand you your top three fixes.
Book it here: https://www.feedbackwrench.com/book
Questions people ask
"Why shouldn't my homepage just list services?"
"A menu lists everything you do, and nobody wakes up in the morning wanting services. A problem asks something that stings, so customers feel it. Customers move when you pull on a problem, not when you list services."
"How do I find the problem to lead with?"
"Find the string to pull. For accountants, it's overpaying in taxes and an accountant who only reacts. Pick the one problem your customers already feel, and say it first."
"Where do my services go on the page?"
"Sprinkle them in after the problem. For example, we do your accounting, bookkeeping and taxes together, so you have books you can defend. Services support the problem, they don't lead it."
"What should the end of the homepage ask people to do?"
"End with one next step, like book a call, and make it the only button that matters on the page."
"How do I avoid sounding manipulative?"
"Say the problem plainly and don't pile on thick, pushy language. Owners can smell that from a mile away. Pull on one real problem, say it plainly, and offer one next step."






